Image shows several trees with a variety of fall colors

This is the topic of a discussion I will lead today, Sept. 27, 3-5pm at Protagonist Books & Coffee (8 W Main St, Dryden, NY.)

As a good ADHDer, I went on a rabbit hole tour. My train of thought went like this:

  • What would make a trait or habit a strength? It would be something that leads a person to fulfill a certain set of desirable characteristics. In this case, leading to being an “ideal” student.
  • How have “ideal” students been described? Is it a well-defined construct?
  • Does the definition of “ideal” student vary by professor, type of course, etc.?
  • What factors influence whether a person fulfills that “ideal”?
  • Are there strengths that are unique to neurodivergent students?

I found some interesting information on websites from a couple of colleges and a peer-reviewed article, which I’ll use to guide our conversation.

A very enlightening quote from that article is:

“to have an ideal student, you’d need an ideal lecturer…
an ideal institution, an ideal society and none of those things coexist”

Related to that idea, we have the “Sense of Coherence,” an idea posited by Aaron Antonovsky. The Sense of Coherence is a great framework to guide our work as educators. It includes three areas:

  1. Comprehensibility: Understanding what is being asked. What do students need to do, by when, how many words / sources / ideas? I have spoken to, at this point, thousands of students about their study habits. Many times, “procrastination” is related to lack of clarity. Students don’t know how much time they need to work on an assignment, or what exactly the assignment is. I think many educators would be surprised to hear how many of their instructions are actually unclear. Our rubrics and instructions have to be crystal clear if we want for students to submit an assignment according to what we really want.
  2. Manageability: Internal and external resources are available. This includes:
    1. Previous knowledge. Have we given enough information to students to be able to work on a given assignment, or are we assuming they should know “that” already? Is the information in the textbook, slides, lecture notes? Do they know where to find it? Do they need to embark a treasure hunt just to find it?
    2. “Study skills.” This goes hand in hand with time management. The part we can control as an institution is to help students not to overcommit, and provide good and clear instruction in time management, task management and more. This is not something you’re born with–humans did not evolve to cope with this era’s demands! and it’s not something you learn along the way. In very competitive schools, where most are incredibly talented and smart, students tend to not “know how to study in college” because they never needed to. The rigor in their high school was not at the level of their capabilities and did not challenge them in the same way that college does. We need to help them based on this assumption: they CAN become very skilled at managing their time and prioritizing/organizing/etc., but they are NOT yet there.
    3. Accommodations and universal design for learning. Is student learning supported by offering needed accommodations? Are professors and TAs trained and use universal design for learning? Meaning, is the information presented in different ways and can students properly process it (i.e., clarity, time allowed for reflection)? Can students communicate or demonstrate their knowledge and skills in different ways as well?
    4. Self-esteem, self-efficacy, self-reliance, self-[fill in the blank]. Faculty and staff really have an impact in this area, starting with the sense of belonging. Are we truly welcoming and make every student feel at home? Do we offer constructive feedback? Do we foster their optimism and belief in themselves?
    5. Consider their family, social and own circumstances. If the student is facing pressure related to housing or food insecurity, doesn’t feel safe, is caring for someone, has a chronic health condition, they may not be able to focus properly. Taking a leave doesn’t help when you are facing life-long conditions or circumstances. People CAN succeed, if we support them and give them grace.
  3. Meaningfulness: what needs to be done is worthy of investment and engagement. This ultimately leads to a feeling that “Life is worth living”. It’s worth considering if all the assignments in a course are meaningful, or if they are “busy work.” Even the knowledge imparted in each course, is it all needed, and to what depth? I think it’s also worth evaluating how much do students really remember the next term, or the following year.

I hope you can come TODAY, Sunday Sept. 27, 3-5pm, to Protagonist Books and Coffee and join the discussion! More info: https://live-protagonist1746481694.pantheonsite.io/event/2026-09-27/author-florencia-ardon

Posted in ,